Babywearing is not a new concept. Mothers have kept their babies close for centuries leaving their hands free to fulfill other duties such as cleaning, cooking, or farming. As you go to choose which carrier is best for you, you might end up wondering the pros and cons of Tula vs Ergo. These are two of the most popular baby brand carriers and it’s hard to know which one you should go with! Luckily, we are here to help with that.
Slings are still available to provide a natural, comfortable environment close to a mother’s body, but baby carriers can offer more structure and ease of use. For mothers who are breastfeeding research found that those who carry babies in carriers increase breastfeeding duration in older babies.
Tula vs Ergo- What to Expect from Both Baby Carriers
Baby carriers have safety standards. To ensure that a baby is safe, follow these guidelines:
- Keep the carrier tight enough to hug the baby close to the body. Too much slack can bring discomfort for the adult wearing it. It can also cause the baby to slump and hinder breathing.
- The baby’s face should be in view at all times.
- Your baby’s head should be close enough to kiss, so it should be as close to your chin as possible.
- The baby’s chin should be at least a finger’s width from their chest. If the chin touches their chest, it can hinder breathing.
- A supported back means that the baby is in a natural position with the tummy and chest against the adult’s body. This allows for a comfortable fit and less slumping.
Tula (babytula.com) and Ergobaby (ergobaby.com) are two brands that are known for comfort, style, safety, and ease for both caregiver and baby.
All About Tula
You will find that this brand offers different carriers for different needs. There are soft structured carriers and coast carriers made with breathable mesh for better ventilation.
Key Features of Soft Structured Tula Carriers
- Easy to wash and made from 100% cotton canvas
- Available in three sizes: Free-to-Grow (7-45 pounds), Standard (15-45 pounds), and Toddler (25-60 pounds)
- Infant Insert is available separately for newborns between 7-15 pounds for additional head and neck support
- Adaptable for front and back carry (back carry is not to be used with Infant Insert)
- Removable hood for head support when sleeping, sun and wind protection, or privacy and comfort during breastfeeding.
- Front pocket on contouring hip belt for storage
- Limited one-year warranty against manufacturing flaws
I love that Tula meets safety standards while ensuring that every baby fits in an ergonomic position. A baby’s weight is spread out evenly, so it is more comfortable for the caregiver wearing the baby. The carrier is also adaptable to fit parents of different builds or caregivers who also need to use the carrier. Users enjoy the supportive shoulder padding which makes wearing more comfortable. In the Tula vs Ergo debate, Tula wins for me as far as comfort goes.
The baby is secure with Duraflex buckles that adjust to every wearer. This also prevents from the carrier to loosen and allow for the baby to slump. The M-position seat supports the baby’s body throughout their development. The leg openings also have extra padding so that it is more comfortable for the baby with less chance of chafing.
The Free-to-Grow model does not require the Infant Insert, but it also does not allow the baby to face forward later. Still, it is a very popular product. The Standard size is ideal for many babies, especially if using the Infant Insert for the first few months as a newborn. The Toddler size continues the connection between parent and older babies for travel, being on-the-go, and much more. All models come in prints that appeal to all styles.
Tula vs Ergo Pricing
These baby carriers are more affordable. Free-to-Grow and Standard carriers are about $139. The larger Toddler carrier is about $169. When ordered from the website, they do offer a military discount.
Tula Toddler Carrier
Finding a really comfortable toddler carrier is definitely tough! Those long legs just seem to get in the way, but your little one still wants to be carried around occasionally. The Tula Toddler Carrier is a great option to remedy this. It can be carried in the front or the back and is designed to hold 25-60 lbs. Bonus, it comes with a great pocket for storage!
Baby Tula Multi Position
This is one of Tula’s most popular baby carriers. You will find it is very comfortable for long term wear. This is because of its wide, padded waist along with dual-adjustment padded straps. It also comes in some of the cutest patterns! Tula vs Ergo; Tula has trendier patterns and colors.
Baby Tula Free to Grow Carrier
This carrier is a great option for mamas who are looking to have just one from infancy through toddlerhood. It is breathable and lightweight while still offering all the support you need. There is a waistband pocket right in the front which is perfect for snacks or your phone. You will also love the removable hood, which provides great sun protection.
Everything to Know About Ergobaby
Ergo has been recognized by numerous institutions and honored with awards including Parents Baby Gear Awards (2018), Cribsie Awards New Arrival (2015), and What to Expect Mom Must-Have Award (2017). The Ergo 360 keeps the baby in close contact but with four positions to choose from. In the Tula vs Ergo debate, Ergo wins in being the most awarded and popular brand.
Key Features of Ergo Carrier
- Machine washable
- Ergo Omni 360 is designed for 7-45 pounds, the Ergo 360 is for 12-45 pounds
- Infant Insert is available separately for newborns between 7-12 pounds for additional head and neck support; the Omni does not require the Infant Insert but can be used from birth to about four years
- Extra large zipper pocket for storage
- Adaptable for front and back carry, but also hip carry and forward facing. Ergo is the only baby carrier that can do that
- Can be used for breastfeeding
- ErgoPromise Lifetime Guarantee
We enjoyed the versatility of the Ergo, particularly the Omni and 360 because of its multiple positions. The pocket makes it easy to hold keys, diapers, and whatever is needed on hand. On the Omni, the storage pouch is detachable. Some users complain that the Velcro belt can be noisy and disturbing if they are taking it off while the baby is sleeping. At the same time, the wide belt is supporting the lower back without feeling buckles dig into the skin.
The Ergo 360 has a deep bucket seat so that the baby is seated more than just dangling in the carrier. Drool pads can be attached to keep the carrier clean without adding plastics near the baby’s mouth.
Parents who choose Ergo also have the confidence in the ErgoPromise Lifetime Guarantee. That means if the carrier or part of the carrier has any manufacturing or material defect, it will be replaced free of charge.
Tula vs Ergo Pricing
The Ergobaby 360 is popular, but the versatility comes with a cost. The Omni 360 is available on the Ergobaby website for about $180 while the 360 is about $160. The Ergobaby Original is about $120.
Adapt Baby Carrier
This is one of Ergobaby’s classic carriers. It offers tons of support and can be used from newborn to toddler. I love that it can be worn on the front, back, or hip so that you and your baby can always switch things up to get comfy! It is ergonomic in all positions and has built-in lumbar support.
This carrier is built for babies 12-33 lbs, but with an additional purchase of the newborn insert, it can be used from 7 lbs. You will love the super wide bottom band which provides extra comfort. I actually think I could wear this carrier all day long! Another perk is the tuck away hood that you can pull up for breastfeeding or sunshade.
Tula vs Ergo- What’s the Conclusion?
Which baby carrier is best for you? It will depend on your needs and use.
In the Tula vs Ergo debate, keep in mind that Tula is more accommodating to higher weight babies. The straps are more comfortable for the adult. It is also more affordable compared to the Ergo.
Ergo offers more carrying positions including hip and outward facing in the 360 model. In terms of selection, Ergo offers many types of fabrics and designs for active lifestyles and has an excellent guarantee.