15 Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies on the Market Right Now!

There are certain products that become a lifeline when you have a new baby; one of those things is undoubtedly a pacifier. Below is a list of the absolute best pacifiers for breastfed babies, so you can give them all a try in your search for the best fit.

Why do you need a pacifier? Well, the pacifier is going to make it possible for you to actually go out to dinner without worrying about the possibility of being “those people” with the screaming baby. The pacifier may make it possible for you to have a peaceful car ride again or simply get some sleep at night. In many cases, they will become a source of comfort for your sweet babe and so will become a source of comfort for mama too. 

Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies in 2022

Things to Consider When Picking Out Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

Now, of course, the pacifiers we have gathered on this list are great for any baby, nursing or formula fed. But, there are just a couple extra factors you should take into consideration when choosing a pacifier for a nursing baby. 

For example, if you are breastfeeding, finding the right pacifier might be a little bit more difficult because you don’t want any nipple confusion going on and you might want to start a bit later. So let’s get started and break it all down for you.

  • When – It is recommended to avoid giving a breastfed baby a pacifier until they are about 4 weeks old. You just want to ensure that they have the whole feeding thing down before you introduce another option and method of soothing to them. I admit, I gave my babies a pacifier sooner than this and they breastfed just fine, but the official recommendation is 4 weeks so I would stick to that if you have any worries.
  • What – The material and size are the most important things to consider when choosing pacifiers. Most pacifiers are made of latex or silicone. Both options are fine but keep in mind latex allergies are quite common. You will also want to make sure that your pacifier is BPA free.
  • How – Some babies take a pacifier right away with no problem, for other babies, it takes some time and occasionally babies won’t take the pacifier at all. All we can say is try a variety of options. The hunt for the best pacifier for your breastfed baby will be well worth it.
  • Be Patient – It often happens that breastfed babies refuse to suckle on a pacifier that just doesn’t feel right to them, which is why we are giving you 15 of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies.

Top 15 Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

WubbaNub Infant Pacifier – Our Favorite for Newborns!

The Wubbanub infant pacifier has been our favorite for a while now. Amongst the moms who have tested many pacifiers the Wubbanub is the most preferred by babies. Our little one spit out several others but loves the Wubbanub.

One of the things we love about Wubbanub is the animal attached to the pacifier which makes it so that dirty hands are not touching the pacifier. Wubbanub is definitely a more pricey pacifier, but when your baby is sucking on it peacefully, it is worth every penny.

Shop Here

Philips Avent Soothie – Orthodontic Design

We could go on and on about this amazing pacifier, but here is the utmost important fact; it is one of the most beloved pacifiers by moms and babies. This pacifier is extremely popular and has been time-tested. It is also the pacifier of choice for many hospitals and has over 3,000 reviews on Amazon.

Check Current Prices Here

Medela Baby Pacifier – Easy to Sterilize

Medela is obviously well known for their incredible breast pumps. However, this brand offers so much more for mom and baby. The Medela Baby Pacifier’s orthodontic shape is designed to support natural suckling for your baby which will help to soothe them.

The one feature I really love as a mom is that this pacifier is easy to clean. It comes with a self-sterilizing case. Just add water and put it in the microwave for 3 minutes and voila, you’ve got a sanitized pacifier.

Check Current Prices Here

The Pop Pacifier – Featured on Shark Tank; the nipple never touches the floor!

The Pop took years of experimenting to get just right, but what they came up with is awesome! If the pacifier takes a tumble to the ground, the nipple will pop back in and stay protected meaning it stays clean!

Of course, the nipple does more than just stay clean though. It has a gentle “pop back” that mimics the real thing from mom making it a great choice for breastfed babes.

Check Them Out Here

Flexy Pacifier

The Flexy is made by Nanobebe. They also make the innovative boobie-shaped bottle to help babies who have to switch between the boob and a bottle! This being said they obviously know what they’re doing when it comes to avoiding nipple confusion.

The nipple is very soft and overall the pacifier contours just right against the baby’s mouth.

Available on Amazon!

The First Years Gumdrop Newborn

This is another very popular pacifier these days. Like the Philips Avent Soothie, it is widely trusted by and used in hospitals. It is designed to be as close in shape to a mom’s nipple as possible. It’s one lightweight piece and cuts low enough to stay away from your baby’s nose.

It’s also pretty reasonably priced and comes in a two-pack!

Check Current Prices Here

PATpat Pacifier – Teether + Pacifier Combo

Nothing better than a 2 for 1 in parenting! This pacifier can also be used as an awesome teether when your baby gets a bit older. The soft nipple will be the next best thing compared to breastfeeding for your little one. It’s also designed to lead to healthy mouth palette development.

Check Current Prices Here

MAM Glow in the Dark Pacifier

Sometimes the most important feature of your pacifier is simply that you are able to find it. Every experienced parent will tell you these things go missing more often than bobby pins and left socks. That is why MAM was genius when they created this one to be glow in the dark.

The MAM Pacifier nipple is also very soft and will feel like mom.

Check Current Prices Here

Ninni Co. Pacifier

This is a newer addition to our list of favorites, but once we tried it out we knew we had to add it! The nipple is thin and soft. It is made to help your baby take a wide-mouth latch just like they do when breastfeeding. Plus, it is perfectly sized and has holes in the base to ensure breathing safety.

Check Current Prices Here

NUK Newborn Silicone Pacifier

Not only is the NUK great for breastfeeding babies, but its orthodontic shape also promotes healthy oral development. Although the shape doesn’t mimic a real nipple very accurately, this shape has been perfected over 50 years and is one of the best at soothing babies.

This is a great choice if you have a baby who’s a little extra fussy and will need the pacifier often because it won’t affect their oral development.

Available on Amazon

Eve Flo Feeding Balance

This pacifier was made with the two most important things in mind; soothing power and the development of healthy sucking skills. The tongue shapes your baby makes when breastfeeding is in fact a skill and this pacifier will require them to make that same tongue shape to suck for soothing purposes.

Check Current Prices Here

Munchkin 2pk Sili-Soothe & Teethe Silicone Pacifier Teether 

This is a multitasking soother that is great for teething babies. They have unique ridges to help soothe sore gums. Plus, they are made from 100% food-grade silicone.

Check Current Prices Here

Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Pacifier – Closest to Real Nipple Shape

Wondering what pacifier is most like a real nipple? The Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Pacifier is an excellent option for moms who want to find a pacifier that’s as close to a real nipple as possible. For breastfed newborn babies, this is the best way to introduce a pacifier and prevent nipple confusion.

Tommee Tippee makes various nipple-shaped pacifiers, but the Closer to Nature version is based on the company’s award-winning Closer to Nature Bottle nipples. These are naturally orthodontic pacifiers, they are BPA-free, and they’re designed with airflow to prevent rashes and irritation around the baby’s mouth.

You can buy the newborn version or a larger version more suited to older babies. 

Check Current Prices Here

Ecopiggy Ecopacifier

If it’s important to you to find an all-natural soother for your baby, this pacifier fits the bill. It’s made from pure rubber harvested from the Hevea Brasiliense rubber tree, and its one-piece design makes it ultra-safe for your little one.

Not only is this pacifier sustainably made, but rubber also has the benefit of being naturally resistant to your baby’s sharp teeth as they begin to come in, meaning you’re unlikely to need to replace these pacifiers due to holes or wear.

It comes in two nipple shapes, with the rounded version said to promote breastfeeding.

Available on Amazon

Dr. Brown’s Happy Paci

As a brand, Dr. Brown’s is known for helping even the most stubborn breastfed babies transition to a bottle, so this pacifier is designed with an incredible likeness to a mother’s nipple.

It’s not just the nipple shape that will remind baby of the real thing; it’s made of 100% silicone to be soft and supple, and the shield is butterfly-shaped to contour around baby’s mouth comfortably. This pacifier is BPA-free and a one-piece design, plus it’s easily cleaned in the dishwasher or bottle sterilizer.

It’s shape also makes it convenient to attach to pacifier clips.

Available on Amazon

There it is, our sweet guide to the best pacifiers for breastfed babies. Now go experiment and see the one your little one loves to soothe them and get a little rest mama. You deserve it.

Know of any other amazing pacifiers? Let us know in the comments

Frequently Asked Questions

Can breastfed babies use pacifiers?

Yes, breastfed babies can use pacifiers. There are many pacifiers out there made specifically for breastfed babies to help avoid any nipple confusion.

What type of pacifier is best for breastfed baby?

A few of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies are:
-WubbaNub Infant Pacifier
-Philips Avent Soothie
-Medela Baby Pacifier
Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Pacifier

Why won’t my breastfed baby take a pacifier?

You may need to try a couple of different pacifiers before you find one that your baby likes. It can also help to put the pacifier in your baby’s mouth and tap it to encourage them to latch.

Can a 1 month old baby use pacifier?

Yes, your baby can use a pacifier from the time they are a newborn. Many parents wait until their baby is established with breastfeeding before introducing a pacifier, but by 1 month most babies are ready.

How many pacifiers do I need?

Start out with 3-4 pacifiers from different brands. When you find the one your baby likes, stock up with at least 2 of their favorites so you always have a backup.

Pin for Later- These Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies are the Best on the Market Right Now!

You Might Also Enjoy:




Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *